I just read an article by Avi Shafran, an Orthodox rabbi who argues that Conservative Judaism has become superfluous since it is betraying its funding idea, which he says is to conserve Jewish religious practice in the face of the threat posed by Reform Judaism.
As always, whether to discriminate gays is seen as the ultimate observance test. Being fair to gay Jews simply will not do if one is to serve God.
In a respond to criticism from the Conservative Rabbi Samuel Fraint, Rabbi Shafran makes this telling comment:
I was, I admit, unaware that the Conservative rule allowing a dissenting opinion requires the opinion to have garnered a certain minimum of votes. My assumption otherwise, however, was hardly essential to my argument that the ground is clearly being prepared for an acceptance of homosexual lifestyles.
And why Rabbi Fraint sees an Orthodox rabbi claiming to be homosexual as pertinent to the question of whether halachah permits homosexual acts is unclear to me. Any “Orthodox rabbi” claiming that halachah sanctions such acts is, ipso facto, not Orthodox in belief.
Why does Orthodox Judaism encourage Torah studies? Why not just hand out booklets with all the right interpretations and shut down discussion altogether? Any reading not completed and written down in the ancient past is rejected anyway.
I could laugh at the arrogance. However, one thing that bothers be about Rabbi Shafran’s smug attitude is that it hurts many Orthodox Jews who struggle to be good men and women but fail to comply with traditional understanding of this one mitzvah, which in an old English translation reads, “Thou shalt not lie with mankind, as with womankind; it is abomination.”
Seriously, I have never had sex with a man as with a woman. And in an Orthodox theological context, I would argue that God knew that gay men do not normally treat their spouses as women or wives, but that it would be a crime to do just that. The mitzvoth are about respect for God, nature, fellow Jews, family, and loved ones—which is precisely why a man should be treated as a man even when making love to another man.